Both of my mom’s parents grew up to be teachers – Grandpa taught chemistry and physics for nearly 40 years, and Grandma taught first grade for over What if not doing homework was better for your kids? I know that is not the answer, but it is a start. So glad the book is serving you well. I grew up without homework in elementary school, so I was already comfortable with the idea.

Children rebel against homework because they have other things they need to do. But overall, less homework and my child is happier. Teachers are constantly under fire for not doing a good enough job. Or go to bed. When school was over for the day, I knew this 6-year-old needed time to run outside, make noise, make faces with his brother, and simply pursue his own interests. I too think homework is silly for younger kids.

Nothing drove me more crazy than having homework assigned to do over Christmas break or spring break – I banned it and on a couple of occasions I had to write notes to the teacher explaining that they would not be completing the assignments over their break but that they would make every effort heafher catch up with it during school time once they returned. As a special education teacher who has taught High School and Early Childhood programs, I have to agree with you.

Along with continual testing for timed reading or math test on a weekly basis.

heather shumaker homework

In college I had trouble with math but the class I finally was allowed to use was applied math. When pressed to give an account of each hour, I would hear about movies they watched, YouTube videos a teacher would show, or how a discussion would last all hour and have absolutely nothing to do with curriculum. Teachers have been dealing with very different and very stressful demands under the No Child Left Behind mandate and are now facing even more stringent requirements regarding testing.


By Heather Shumaker March 8, There are several good homesork presenting in-depth research against homework: I believe it completely discourages my child to study and do homework in the future when she hits high school.

heather shumaker homework

My daughter is about to start kindergarten. My kids’ school is pretty good.

heather shumaker homework

More parents should consider home educating! It’s not fair on kids and it’s not fair on families. He still has homework but he is not up until 2 AM seriously like his classmates. I think the point that many teachers and parents miss here is that the parent is supposed to be in control of the house, not the teacher, school, or government.

There is plenty of time to turn them into rule obeying worker drones during their over-exam taking teenage years.

With no academic benefit, there are simply better uses for after-school hours. I don’t really homfwork in homework, even for my middle schoolers, unless it truly supports what we’ve done in the classroom that day.

Thanks to her flexibility and understanding of individual needs, the year went by without a glitch. I also agree with the person who commented about city kids, that was my situation.

Why We Say “NO” to Homework – Heather Shumaker

Send that letter ASAP! A child just beginning school deserves the chance to develop a love of learning. When my son comes home with homework that is really homework for ME because it requires so much helpI resent it. The child needs to win.


Homework Letter Update

Most teachers would be glad to point you to additional resources you can try at home. If we pride ourselves on a rational, research-based approach to education, we must look at the right facts. By high school my stepdaughter would arrive at school at 6am for dance team practice, get home at 4: So I know it is successful Even in preschool and kindergarten. And that’s exactly the hardest point for my 5th grader. We don’t have control over state testing, nor are we allowed to voice our opinions, without risking homewor, paychecks.

It also makes me the enemy in my own home. With that said my son is in first grade and does not officially have homework, but brings home a practice worksheet with several activities to complete in order to reinforce the weeks lessons. I hfather think I am ready to ban it from the household, as she is enjoying it, I DO however, need to do better by our family to make sure I am not the one making it an unpleasant or stressful experience.

Here they are “in Greece” Well actually in Fort Langley, BC, learning about Greece during one such day filled with experiences that no textbooks or worksheets could ever replicate:.